中国农村金融改革历程经验教训.PPT

《中国农村金融改革历程经验教训.PPT》由会员分享，可在线阅读，更多相关《中国农村金融改革历程经验教训.PPT（33页珍藏版）》请在三一办公上搜索。

1、中国农村金融改革：历程、经验、教训,世界银行高级金融专家 王君Email:jwang3worldbank.org2007年11月20日亚太财经与发展中心农村金融培训班,农村金融的概念,什么是“三农”？农村农业农民什么是农村金融？贷款存款支付保险租赁贸易融资（trade credit)其他,农村金融的需求与供给,需求的多样性农户种植养殖副业婚丧嫁娶治病等农民工企业微型小型中型村镇政府供给正规金融机构民间借贷,农村金融改革历程回顾,农业合作化运动中产生的农信社成立专业银行成立政策性银行对农村金融市场实行保护和限制实行以低利率、高补贴的农村金融政策改革农信社1997年亚洲金融危机之后：恢复其合作制性

2、质2003-2006：注资；明确所有者；移交省政府（成立省联社）2007年：新的一轮改革试点开始小额信贷试点（人民银行主导的）2006年12月以来：降低农村金融市场准入门槛（银监会主导的）村镇银行贷款公司村级农村金融互助组织农发行农业银行邮政储蓄银行,中国农村金融的现状Current status of rural finance in China,农业占GDP的比重在大幅度下降 Share of agricultural production in GDP has been on the decline对“三农”的关注表明从旧范式向新范式过渡 Concern over san nong in

3、dicates transition from the old to the new paradigm但是仍然在实行对农业信贷的补贴 However subsidized lending to agriculture continues农村存贷款利率逐步放宽但仍缺乏足够的灵活性 Rural interest rates have been deregulated to large extent but still insufficient仍然缺乏扶助性的农村金融监管制度 Absence of an enabling regulatory regime needed for sustainabl

4、e rural-and micro-finance农村金融的基础设施仍然不健全 Continued lack of public infrastructure for rural finance,农村金融的特点：风险大成本高 Characteristics of rural finance,风险大 High risks季节性波动 Seasonal fluctuations协方差风险 Covariance risks规模小并且市场分割 Small size of production and fragmented markets缺乏传统的抵押物 Lack of traditional colla

5、teral保险和劳动力市场不配套 Poorly complementary insurance and labor markets基础设施不健全 Lack of physical and public infrastructure,农村金融的目标,减轻贫困？增加农民收入？保证农业稳定县域经济？保护农村信用社？防止财政风险？为农村的企业和农户提供金融服务？,教训之一：误把农村金融当作农业信贷Lesson one:RF mistaken as agricultural credit,很多政府把为传统的初级农业提供信贷当作是农村金融 Many governments equated primary

6、agricultural credit to rural finance因为初级农产品价格往往随着产量的增加而下降，因此农民的收入得不到提高 As prices of primary agricultural products tend to decline with growing supply,farmers income are often suppressed出于对食品安全和农民福利的考虑，政府往往通过增加补贴的办法试图扩大农业信贷规模 Out of consideration for food safety and welfare of the farmers,governments

7、 have a tendency to increase agricultural credit through subsidies,教训之二：扭曲的资金价格导致资源错配Lesson two:distorted prices lead to misallocation,这种范式的突出特点是实行低利率、补贴贷款和指令性信贷计划 An important feature of this paradigm is to impose regulated low interest rates and subsidized and directed lending由此使得那些能够产生较高回报的经济活动反而

8、得不到融资,从而导致资源分配的扭曲 Those economic activities with high potential returns are crowded out,resulting in misallocation of resources实证研究表明政府在农村基础设施、教育、卫生领域的投资实际上更有效率 Empirical evidence is abundant that investment in rural infrastructure,education and health generates tremendous higher returns than direct

9、 household subsidy,农业信贷补贴与医疗及基础教育融资效益比较Comparing Agricultural Credit Subsides with Funding for Preventative Health and Basic Education,教训之三：补贴反而造成更大的不公平Lesson three:subsidy worsens social inequality,补贴的本意是减轻贫困农民的负担 The motivation behind subsidy is to lessen the burden of poor farmers然而全世界普遍的现象是低利率贷款

10、往往被那些有权有势的人获得 However it is universally true that subsidized loans are often grabbed by the rich and influential其结果反而使富者更富，从而加剧了社会的不公平 Consequently the rich becomes richer therefore making the social inequality even worse指令性贷款和补贴贷款治标不治本，无法从根本上解决金融市场效率低下的问题 Directed,subsidized credit was a poor respo

11、nse to the symptoms without addressing the root cause of poorly performing Rural Financial Markets(RFMs),教训之四：低估农民创造价值的能力Lesson four:underestimation of farmers ability,很多人认为农民作为弱势群体没有能力承担较高利率 Many believe the farmers are unable to bear higher interest rates as they are the weak and vulnerable从而认为农村小

12、额信贷必须实行低利率 Therefore believing that rural microfinance must be provided at low interest rate这种认识往往来源于错误地把社会平均利润率等同于边际投资回报率 Such erroneous thinking often stems from mistaking average social returns as marginal investment returns,教训之五:旧的范式加剧农村金融机构的问题Lesson five:the old paradigm weakens RFIs,低利率和指令性信贷政

13、策使得农村金融机构没有动力实行商业化经营 Regulated interest rates and directed lending take away incentives for RFIs to assume commercial orientation因为按照低利率每发放一笔贷款都意味着产生新的亏损 As each new loan implies additional loss at the less than equilibrium interest rates只要有政府干预存在这些农村金融机构就有理由指望在发生亏损的时候政府会对其实行监管宽容或救助 As long as gover

14、nment intervention continues these RFIs have reason to expect regulatory forbearance or direct bailout,2%4%6%8%10%12%14%16%18%20%22%24%26%28%30%Interest Rate Paid by RFI on its Borrowed Funds主要假设：股本占总资产的10%，年度平均总资产回报率是20%，管理费用占总资产的6%。Key Assumptions:equity equals 10 percent of total assets,the avera

15、ge annual yield obtained on total assets is 20 percent,and administrative expenses are six percent of total assets./,教训之六:错把较高的市场利率视作高利贷Lesson six:regarding high interest rates as usurious,传统上有些国家把高于管制的利率视作高利贷 Traditionally some governments regard any interest rates above the regulated rates as usur

16、ious也有的国家法律设定一个标准，超过即视为高利贷 And still others have legislations providing for a threshold for usurious interest rates然而那种按照一定绝对额设定高利贷界限的做法已经过时了 However it is outdated practice to pinpoint an absolute value as usurious interest rate实际上只要借款者能够在偿还贷款本息之后仍有利润空间利率就不是高利贷 As long as the borrower is able to ge

17、nerate profit after paying interest and principle the interest rate is not usurious,微型贷款为什么需要高利率Why lending rate for microloans needs to be high,占1万元贷款平均成本the percentage cost for a$10,000 loan,0.25%,25%,占100元贷款平均成本the percentage cost for a$100 loan,如果利率不变银行肯定不愿意发放小额贷款,教训之七:政府的预算是有限的因此补贴不是办法Lesson se

18、ven:there is a limit to the state budget,在任何情况下政府的预算都是有限的，因此政府面临两难选择 In any given situation the government capacity to provide subsidy is limited,therefore the government is confronted with a cruel dilemma也就是说到底是以较高的补贴但是却只能使较少的人受惠 Namely to provide relatively higher subsidy but only to reach fewer r

19、ural households或者以较低甚至是零补贴但是却能使有限的资金惠及更多的目标人群 Or to reach more households with lower or even zero subsidy没有任何政府能够避开这种选择 No government can escape from this cruel dilemma,问题是政府面临残酷的两难选择But there is a cruel dilemma,在财政约束条件下每单位贷款 faced with budget constraints,for each unit lent:,或者以较少乃至零补贴使更多的目标人群得到实惠 e

20、ither benefit more target group with less or zero subsidy,或者以较多的补贴使较少的目标人群得到实惠or benefit less target group with more subsidy,Urban areas,高收入客户,低收入客户,目前提供的服务,商业可持续边界,城市,农村,市场效率差距,微型金融的商业可持续边界Frontier of commercial microfinance,教训之八：政府办农村金融机构很少有成功的Lesson eight:governments are not good at running rural

21、 financial institutions,从国际范围看只有少数国家的国有金融机构取得成功 Worldwide there are only a few countries that have successful state-owned financial institutions而这些国家往往有较为健全的市场经济和良好的法律环境 And those countries without exception have relatively advanced market economy and conducive legal environment若想成为成功的金融机构所有者除非政府模仿私

22、人所有者把利润最大化作为首要目标 The government as owner can succeed only if it mimics private owners with profit maximization as the only objective但是常识告诉我们这对于政府是极为困难的 But common sense has it that it is almost next to impossible for government to do so,教训之九:过度的监管可能会扼杀农村金融Lesson nine:overly intrusive regulation coul

23、d stifle RF,很多国家是先有农村金融（小额信贷）后有监管 In many countries development of rural/micro finance leads regulation对于那些并不吸收公众存款的农村小额信贷没有必要对其实行审慎监管 It is not advisable to impose prudential regulation over RFIs that do not take public deposits即使是这类农村小额信贷也需要以机构为基础才有可能持久发展 However such microfinance needs to be inst

24、itution-based to be sustainable这样就需要有扶助性的农村金融监管框架 Thus there is strong need for enabling regulatory framework for rural finance,教训之十:不当的评价标准导致错误的战略与政策 Lesson ten:inappropriate performance criteria could lead to wrong strategies and policies,多数农村金融机构被大量补贴,其“利润”通常是大量补贴后的剩余价值 Most rural DFIs are heavil

25、y subsidized.Their“profit”is usually a residual value of a substantial subsidy they consume.“投资回报”其实不是真正的回报 The“return”is no real return,中国从国际教训的可借鉴之处What can China learn from those lessons,增加农村收入和减少贫困的努力必须考虑整个农村产业，而不仅仅是农民 Rural income generation and poverty alleviation efforts must take into accoun

26、ts the entire rural sector,not just farmers如果及时拨付贷款，信贷条件合理，小规模的农户能够、也愿意付适当高的利率 Small-scale farmers are able and willing to pay appropriately high interest rates if loan disbursement is timely and credit conditions are appropriate,政府的作用 Role of Government,旧角色 OLD直接干预及管理农业信贷的数量与价格 To directly interven

27、e and administer agricultural credit quantity and price,新角色 NEW最大限度地减少直接干预和信贷控制,以创造一个良好的政策环境To create a favorable policy environment,while minimizing direct intervention,政府的作用：农村金融机构,农业银行农村信用社邮政储蓄银行农业发展银行村镇银行小额贷款公司村级合作金融组织,政府的作用,建立有担保的交易框架概念：什么可以作为抵押？法律：保护债权人还是债务人？如何确立优先规则？公示：登记还是备案？查询：时间、成本？执行：保护债权

28、人还是保护债务人？,政府的作用：如何设计和发放补贴,如何把有限的公共资源用到该用的地方补贴谁？怎样补贴？是否要评价效果？怎样评价？避免挤出民间投资者避免扭曲市场机制避免加剧赖帐文化,如何实现业绩的最优化Optimizing performance in rural finance,对目标客户群的金融服务覆盖面大并且具有可持续性Sustainable financial services that reach the target clients,对目标客户群的金融服务覆盖面大但是补贴程度也高Highly subsidized financial services that reach the

29、target Clients,对目标客户群的金融服务覆盖面小并且补贴程度高Highly subsidized financial services with low outreach to target clients,对目标客户群的金融服务覆盖面较小但是有可持续性Sustainable financial services with low outreach to the target clients,覆盖面大,覆盖面小,自我持续性强 High Self-Sustainability,自我持续性低 Low Self-Sustainibility,Source:Adapted from Maj

30、ahan,1994.,农村金融机构业绩的评价标准 Criteria For Assessing-The Performance of RFIs,主要评价标准,自我持续性,目标客户覆盖面,成份指数:补贴指数将补贴与利息收入比较,混合指数:评价覆盖面与服务质量,补贴举例:国家承担贷款损失优惠贷款的利率补贴资本金的机会成本准备金豁免,举例:市场占有率相对收入水平、服务质量存款额贷款额,补贴依赖指数作为一种分析框架 Subsidy Dependence Index as a framework,补贴依赖指数提供了衡量农村金融机构绩效的方法 The SDI provides a methodology

31、to measure the true performance of RFIs同时也提供了一种分析框架 Meanwhile it is also an analytical framework 可以为农村金融改革和发展提供一种新的视角 provding a new perspective in approaching rural finance reform and development,补贴依赖指数 Subsidy Dependence Index(SDI),The SDI measures the percentage increase in the RFI average on-len

32、ding interest rate required to compensate for eliminating all subsidies received by the RFI 补贴依赖指数衡量的是，假如取消对农村金融机构补贴，其平均贷款利率增长的百分比 SDI=S/(LP x I)；SDI=RFIs subsidy dependence index（农村金融机构的补贴依赖指数）LP=Avg.annual outstanding loan portfolio of the RFI（农村金融机构年度平均贷款余额）I=Avg.on lending interest rate of the R

33、FI（农村金融机构平均贷款利率）,补贴依赖指数（续）Subsidy Dependence Index(SDI)(contd),S=补贴总额；S=Total subsidies;市场资金成本与会计成本之差乘以年均借款额 Difference between market and accounting cost of funds multiplied by annual average borrowed funds;股本的机会成本及 Opportunity cost of equity and;所有其它补贴 All other subsidies,我们从本部分学到了什么？What have we

34、learned from this session?,实现商业可持续性是扩大农村金融覆盖面和减少补贴依赖的根本途径 Commercial sustainability is the way to expanded outreach and reduced dependency dependency扶助性的农村金融监管框架有助于实现上述目标 An enabling regulatory framework helps achieving the goal of commercialization of rural finance决策者和监管者改变观念是成功的第一步 Change in mindset is the first necessary step,