中国的崛起对俄罗斯是借鉴否IsChinaaModelforRussia.ppt

《中国的崛起对俄罗斯是借鉴否IsChinaaModelforRussia.ppt》由会员分享，可在线阅读，更多相关《中国的崛起对俄罗斯是借鉴否IsChinaaModelforRussia.ppt（13页珍藏版）》请在三一办公上搜索。

1、Is China a Model for Russia?Comparing Dominant and One-Party Systems,Jean C.Robinson,Chief Reader,AP Comp GoPoProfessor of Political Science,Indiana Universityrobinsoindiana.edu,2010 Advanced Placement Annual Conference,AP Comparative Government&Politics,“Everyone here sees China as the model,since

2、Russia is not the model.”D.Kosyrev,SOURCE:New York Times October 18,2009,Wang Jianwei/Xinhua,Learning outcomes:,We will discuss key factors for distinguishing among different types of party and party systems and develop methods for teaching these distinctions to students.We will develop analytic cat

3、egories for determining whether China might be a model for Russia,by comparing how different kinds of party systems might be more effective with regard to efficiency,corruption,and meeting social needs.You will be provided with some data on measures of party membership,stability,economic growth,and

4、corruption for both countries,and then design student assignments that use the measures to compare the party systems,paying special attention to multi party,dominant party and single party systems.,What is it that Russian leaders see as admirable about Chinese party system?,And what can this tell us

5、 about ways to compare teach and compare political parties?Party System TypologiesTwo partyMulti PartyOne Party(dominant party),Two Party and Multi Party Systems,TWO PARTY:TWO POLITICAL PARTIES DOMINANT TO SUCH AN EXTENT THAT ELECTORAL SUCCESS UNDER THE BANNER OF A THIRD PARTY IS ALMOST IMPOSSIBLE.O

6、FTEN THE BREADTH OF REPRESENTATION OF POLITICAL VALUES AND IDEOLOGIES IS LIMITED,AND OFTEN THE POLITICAL STANCES OF THE TWO PARTIES CONVERGE ON SOME SHARED CONSENSUS.MULTI PARTY:SYSTEMS IN WHICH MORE THAN TWO PARTIES COMPETE,REPRESENT DIVERSE POLITICAL INTERESTS,AND ARE ELECTED TO PUBLIC OFFICE.OFTE

7、N SUCH PARTY SYSTEMS RESULT IN COALITION GOVERNMENTS,AND MORE INTRICATE ELECTORAL SYSTEMS(SECOND BALLOTS,E.G.),Single and Dominant Party Systems,One Party:single party is legally allowed to hold effective power.Although minor parties may sometimes be allowed,they are legally required to accept the l

8、eadership of the dominant party.China:CCPDominant Party:One strong party,that is not likely to be defeated,whether because of formal rules or informal practices.Opposition parties are allowed,and there may be even a deeply established democratic tradition,but other parties are generally considered t

9、o have no real chance of gaining power.Russia and United Russia?,Why would Russia model China?The advantages of a dominant party or single party system,Greater controlLess cost(time,resources)Greater policy/implemention efficiencyOther?,Comparing Parties&Party Systems,What other ways to compare?IdeologyStructure SizePenetrationCompetitivenessDiffusionEffectiveness,United Russia Party,Characteristics in 2009-10,Chinese Communist Party,Characteristics in 2009-10,Back to Comparing Parties&Party Systems,An approach,Back to the USSR?,Questions&Contact Info,Jean Robinsonrobinsoindiana.edu,